The following questions have been submitted by osteopathic medical students through a network of SOMA volunteers at each college of osteopathic medicine.
What is single accreditation?
Why is the system changing? Is the purpose to create more residency slots?
Several factors influenced the decision made by the AOA, ACGME and AACOM to transition to a single accreditation system. The new approach will provide consistent methods for evaluation and accountability, enhance opportunities for all trainees and provide transparency to outside entities, including the federal government, licensing boards, credentialing committees and the public.
Why is this happening if students are currently able to match in MD
spots in ACGME programs?
In October 2011, the ACGME released new Common Program Requirements that severely limited DOs' ability to move from AOA residency training into advanced ACGME training. A major goal of the single GME accreditation system is to ensure that osteopathic students and graduates continue to have unrestricted access to training opportunities in specialties and locations of their choosing.
Were students involved during this process?
Yes, students representatives have served on the AOA Board of Trustees and House of Delegates, providing critical input throughout the transition process.
What documents and agreements have transpired between AOA
A Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), which is a private legal document approved by the AOA, the ACGME, and AACOM, identifies the roles and commitments of each organization in transitioning to
the single system. The MOU describes
ACGME governance changes, review committee changes, and benefits for programs
(and residents) applying for ACGME accreditation. Most of the information in the MOU has been communicated in the AOA and ACGME FAQs.
vs. MD applicants
Will MD applicants be given preference over
DO applicants in competitive residencies when there is one single accreditation
system, since we will no longer have DO-only residencies?
Neither the AOA nor ACGME controls which applicants are chosen for specific programs. However, program directors are looking for residents who will complement and be an
asset to their program. Competitive
ACGME programs have sought and accepted osteopathic medical graduates for many
years. We have every confidence that DO graduates
are well qualified and will continue to have opportunities in competitive residency
Is the AOA able to predict if traditionally-MD
residencies are going to accept more DO graduates after the merger,
or are they still going to preferentially reserve spots for MDs? Some students are concerned there will be a surplus of DOs and a shortage of spots, especially if some
DO residency programs are not accepting further students and/or not planning to
apply for dual accreditation.
At the time of the
MOU, approximately 50% of osteopathic graduates were training in
ACGME (MD) residencies. The AOA is not
able to predict if ACGME residencies are going to accept more DO graduates, but
we believe that the single accreditation system builds on already positive impressions of DOs among
ACGME programs. We do know that DO
graduates are well qualified and should do well in the new environment.
How do we know ACGME programs will accept us?
Currently, almost half of all DO graduates
enter directly into ACGME residency programs upon graduation from a college of osteopathic medicine. There is no reason for these programs
to stop accepting DOs, and the positive environment fostered by the single accreditation system may
open new possibilities with ACGME program directors who perceived an unfair
imbalance when AOA-accredited programs accepted only osteopathic graduates.
Will there be a parallel or subsequent increase in the
number of residency spots at accredited programs?
New programs continue to seek approval from
AOA and ACGME. However, the transition
to a single accreditation system on its own will not create new positions because as AOA programs gain
ACGME accreditation, they will eventually drop AOA accreditation.
Will other accredited sites have the resources to take a
new resident into an existing class?
This varies from site to site, depending on
whether it has the facilities, patient volume and financial support needed
to take additional residents. There must
be adequate scope, volume and variety of cases for a training program to accept
an additional trainee. However, facilitating the transition of residents from
closing programs to accredited programs is not a new process or issue. Several dozen ACGME- and AOA-accredited postdoctoral
programs close each year. Hence, there are established mechanisms to help move
residents from closing programs. ACGME,
AOA and AACOM all place emphasis on allowing residents to complete
training in accredited settings and advance to board eligibility. In addition, the Centers for Medicare and
Medicaid Services administers the majority of funds for residency training and
has rules that allow for moving GME funds with the residents.
What are the Residency Intern Year
requirements for specific states? For instance, I have heard there are
specific requirements for Florida and Pennsylvania in regards to intern year
that could potentially make you ineligible to work in those states if you do
not meet the intern year requirements as a DO. I am a DO student completing
an allopathic PM&R residency with a potential intern year in a
different location from the PM&R residency.
There are two aspects of your situation
that need to be considered. First, the
PM&R Review Committee will allow programs to accept residents from either
an AOA internship or an ACGME transitional year. Please see: Eligibility
FAQs for Specialties with a Preliminary Year, which provides some advice
on board certification considerations.
Second, Florida, Pennsylvania, and Oklahoma require an AOA
internship year in order to obtain a license in one of those states. The AOA has been working to advise these and other
state licensing boards regarding the expected impact of the single accreditation system on AOA internships. If you complete an
ACGME transitional year program, you will need to have your training recognized
by the AOA. For more information, see AOA
Recognition for ACGME Training.
If a 4th year student graduates from an ACGME accredited
program, will he/she still be eligible for an NMM/OMM plus 1 fellowship, since all
residencies that will continue to accept students will be ACGME-accredited at
that time? Also, if you graduate from an AOA program that dissolves following
graduation, will you be eligible for fellowships?
The eligibility requirements for an
AOA-accredited plus 1 OMM residency are:
Successfully complete an AOA-approved residency program in another specialty.
Be and remain a member in good standing of the AAO.
During the residency training program, the resident must meet the requirements as outlined in the Basic Standards for Residency Training in NMM/OMM.
For more information, view the Basic Standards for "Plus One" Residency Training in Neuromusculoskeletal Medicine and Osteopathic Manipulative Medicine.
The primary eligibility requirement for an
ACGME ONMM2 position (which is similar to the AOA plus 1 OMM fellowship) is:
For more information, view the ACGME ONMM
Note that after 2020,
the AOA will cease its accreditation activities. This means that there will no longer be a
plus 1 OMM program and the only option will be the ACGME ONMM2.
After the transition, will there be two applications or one unified application system to
apply for residency?
Once the transition to
a single accreditation system is complete, the AOA Match will no longer be needed. Therefore, there will not be an AOA Match
application. The primary Matching
service for ACGME programs is the NRMP.
However, the NRMP is not the only match program. Others include the San Francisco Match,
the Urology Match, and the Military Match.
Will the class of 2020 be the last class to use two residency application services?
We anticipate that the
class of 2019 will likely be the last class using two application services,
unless we can accelerate our programs into the single accreditation system
sooner, in which case the class of 2018 might be the last class to use two residency matches. Here’s why: The class of 2020 graduates from osteopathic
medical schools in May 2020. All AOA
programs at that time will be either ACGME programs or ineligible to accept new
residents (because they will no longer have AOA accreditation after June 30, 2020). All 2020 graduates will be entering ACGME
programs and will match through the National Residency Matching Service.
Residency programs that do not meet deadlines or requirements for accreditation
Can four-year programs that do not apply for accreditation by Dec. 31, 2016, accept residents for PGY-2
year if the residents apply the following year?
An AOA training program may accept trainees
if the trainees can complete their training by June 30, 2020. If the trainee would complete their training
after June 30, 2020, the program must apply for ACGME accreditation by the date
listed in the Program Accreditation Deadline Chart.
Can you ensure residents will be transferred
to an accredited program if their own program fails to receive accreditation
upon their completion of the program?
The AOA will cease accrediting programs
after June 30, 2020. Programs that have not achieved ACGME accreditation by
that date will not be accredited for continuing residency training. AOA and
ACGME residency programs have closed in the past. In these situations, the AOA has typically
worked to transition residents in closing programs into open
slots in other accredited programs. We
understand that ACGME has also worked to facilitate transition of residents if
and when programs close. The AOA and
ACGME want residents to have an opportunity to complete residency training and
advance to board eligibility. Neither
the AOA nor the ACGME wishes to harm residents and will look at each resident’s
situation on a case-by-case basis in an effort to identify appropriate
Which scores will be released to residency programs during the application
cycle? For instance, if a program is ACGME-accredited and the student applying
takes both the COMLEX and the USMLE, will they be able to choose which scores
are released to the programs?
Please view pages 30-35 of the Electronic Residency Application Service (ERAS) 2017 Guide.
Osteopathic recognition and board certification
What is the outlook on the number of
programs seeking osteopathic recognition? Are any traditionally allopathic residencies
The outlook is promising. Keeping in mind
that programs cannot apply for osteopathic recognition until they receive ACGME
accreditation, we are pleased that more than 75 applications for osteopathic recognition from both AOA and ACGME accredited programs have already been filed. You can monitor the progress of osteopathic recognition applications online. A number of ACGME-accredited residencies are pursuing osteopathic recognition. Not surprisingly, as of December 2016, the
largest group applying for osteopathic recognition have been dually-accredited programs.
Are there avenues for residents to further their osteopathic
training within a chosen specialty if they end up in a non-AOA residency
program, and if so, would they be able to sit for AOA boards upon completion of
The AOA currently has a
process for recognizing ACGME training to allow DOs to become board-eligible in
their respective specialties. You can view the list of requirements in the AOA Recognition for ACGME Training section. If you have additional questions on the recognition
process, please feel free to contact our Trainee Services team.